Saturday, August 8, 2009

Life on the Record

The last few years, and in reality, these very days now are defining moments in history. I’m not talking about the global financial crisis, global warming or the challenges of globalization. I’m talking about technology, the internet and in particular social networking mechanisms. Society as we know it is under fire.

The growing global subscription to Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin, My Space and other such phenomena is fundamentally changing people and challenging the core protocols of our society. The most interesting thing is people seem to be signing up to share their lives, every thought and movement with gay abandon. Not pausing for a second to consider the longer term or even immediate implications of such personal disclosure – which only a few years ago would have been deemed recklessly dangerous to reveal. Of course people’s intention is to share private information only with their so-called “friends” but when you see that some people have 500 plus “friends” I wonder whether it’s more accurate to describe the majority as “acquaintances”. Even more troubling is the exponential nature of networks that enable your friends to share information with their friends and then their friends’ friends and so on. It’s like an uncontrollable virus of public disclosure. The moment you put yourself out there on the internet, no matter how tight your initial circle is, you must accept there is no limit to the potential spread of whatever content you post – and you’ll never know who’s seeing what. So why do people do it? Everyone is doing it: kids, singles, couples, families, celebrities, politicians and priests. Despite many people becoming slaves to the ritual of constantly updating the content, these cyber social networkers love the efficiency of having a mass communication platform to share with their “network”. They also seem drawn to notion of being a public figure, perhaps reflecting a recessed egotistical trait in most of us.

One thing that seems for certain is that our “cyber identity” is the only truly lasting one. In fact, our cyber identity even outlasts our body. It is now possible to subscribe to a service that automatically sends emails on our behalf, perhaps commemorating important occasions, to our family and friends from the grave! Think about how many times in life your phone number changes, your work address and home address change. For most of us the answer is “many times”. Keeping up with these changes in others’ lives proves difficult given the frequency. Think now about your personal email address, almost everyone has one (some have more than one). We are 20 years into the “email age” and there hasn’t been an apocalyptic moment when everyone’s personal email address has had to change. The likelihood of such an event ever happening seems increasingly remote as the internet becomes more robust and stable. So, for many of us in our twenties, thirties and forties our personal email is already our longest standing contact address of any kind and clearly will be in the future. For today’s children, their personal email address (or its future derivate forms) will be a ‘life-long’ identity and therefore the most important ‘branding’ decision of their life. My daughter Aria is 6 years old and already has her own personal email address. It is possible if she keeps herself healthy, she will have that exact address, that ‘label’ and conduit to the world for 100 years!

The startling reality that our cyber identity is the most durable has already begun to recalibrate our lives (or will soon). Gradually home addresses, hand written letters or even posted letters, phone calls, land lines, photographic film processing, birthday cards, posted event invitations etc and slipping away into history. Of course these are being replaced with wonderfully efficient contemporary practices of instant messaging, group emails, bulletin boards, links to on-line photo albums, and e-vites. Our identity is more and more becoming the one we’ve created online. How often do you ask for someone’s postal address as opposed to email address? While relishing in this new hyper-connectivity we enjoy with ‘friends’ around the world, are we becoming lazy, getting distracted or worse still forgetting how to actually speak to someone? Maybe not yet, maybe you still call your mother on her birthday. How about the youth of 2020 and beyond, will they?

Before you decide I’m old-fashioned, know that I registered the email address for Aria and I myself have dabbled into Facebook. I treasure the customs of the past, but recognize the popular realities of the future. As we adopt new ways of interacting with each other, I hope it is not at the expense of face to face meetings and hearing someone’s voice. I wonder whether people worried about losing the intimacy of human interaction when the telephone was invented in the late 19th century? Perhaps for a moment.

The concept of a “cyber identity” is more than just a personal email address. The internet and social networking sites are facilitating a new social trend of individualism. The mass communication platform created by technology allows almost anyone to act out their own sense of “celebritism”. Whether it is putting your video clip on You Tube, writing a blog, creating a vast profile and photographic record on Facebook, or broadcasting the real-time minutia of one’s daily life on Twitter – it is all fostering a “here I am, look at me” mass culture. Every one of us now has the communication technology at our fingertips to be the producer, director and star of our own broadcast life. The parallel in the TV industry has been the emergence and saturation of “reality” programs where literally anybody can become a media identity. Generation-Y’s overwhelming tendency to ‘project outwards’ is engendering a self-aggrandizing culture which is not conducive to a harmonious society. Some may argue the opposite, protesting that this hyper-interaction is actually bringing people closer, facilitating understanding across cultures – some of that is true. However, the velocity of this social trend is fuelled by a corrupted celebrity culture currently gripping the world. The media has made entertainers (I use that term broadly to describe actors, musicians, sportspeople, models and the like) whether talented or not, the cultural opinion leaders of the modern era. Gone are the academics, authors, philosophers, poets, tycoons, scientists, intellectuals, popes and politicians – unless of course they have celebrity appeal. So with this denigration of social leadership into the pages of gossip magazines, it is no surprise that free mass communication tools that give any Tom, Dick or Harriet an opportunity to ‘promote’ and ‘share’ themselves are being subscribed to at a mind-boggling rate. Another counter argument is these internet platforms create a more ‘level playing field’ for the identification and development of talent. There are countless examples of amateur film makers who attracted attention and funding as a result of You Tube, there are even child actors who have been ‘discovered’ as a consequence of posting personal video clips on the internet. The same is true of amateur bloggers, who have so many ‘followers’ that publishing companies have offered them book deals or a column in the newspaper. Without these cyber stars maybe we would be living in a less enriched world ……..

It is not unusual for the consequences of great social change to be both constructive and corrosive. With social networking sites we’re experiencing both, but we’re preoccupied mostly with the benefits. There is a reason we instinctively create ‘layers’ of information disclosure in our life, ranging from the intimacy we share with our family to the distance and guarded manner in which we relate to strangers. This instinct is primal, it is our way of surviving. We all seem to ‘get it’ when dealing with people in the flesh, it would serve us well to remember it in cyberland.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Pure Class

Today I received a phone call from Mr. Bruce Rockowitz, Chairman of Pure Group in response to my letter of last week.

I was impressed by the fact he chose to call me rather than respond in writing. Moreover, his manner and responsiveness to my critique was extraordinary, he is a class act. It was clear the contents of my assessment had been taken seriously and were being actioned with a sense of purpose and urgency. He had already conducted several discussions with his senior management and has subsequently organised a meeting for me with the Group's CEO to discuss some of my comments and suggestions.

It is a rare quality for a business and its leader to take criticism, even the constructive type, on the chin and then turn it into an action plan for improvement so rapidly. Mr. Rockowitz is a great role model for the rest of us.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Not So Pure

I sent this letter to the owner and founder of my gym today. A small effort to rectify a daily frustration in life. We'll see what sort of response this provokes.

Bruce Rockowitz
Chairman
Pure Group
15F Asia Standard Tower
59-65 Queens Road Central
Hong Kong

20 May 2009

Dear Bruce,

It may seem slightly obtuse or at the very least atypical to be addressing a comment about the operations of a business to its Non-executive Chairman. However given your strong stewardship and public association with Pure, coupled with my exasperation with Pure’s operational staff, I thought it best to reach out directly to you.

In these difficult economic times we are reminded of core business values that underpin every organisation’s success. One of which is the old mantra: “No matter what business we are in, we are in the people business”. Given Pure is positioned as a “lifestyle” business; one could reasonably assume Pure to be more of a people business than an average business. In this context the growing consensus among members is all the more concerning. There is now an explicit, albeit perhaps unheard or unnoticed, momentum among members moving away from Pure. This movement is manifesting on the street, in offices, around dinner tables and is spreading fast.

The challenge is that members don’t tend to advocate their dissatisfaction or try to ‘fix’ whatever their problem is, instead, they apathetically wait until the end of their contract period and then just don’t extend. Others do make suggestions/comments through the mandated channel, then get frustrated when there is no follow-up, response or impact of their effort to improve things. This may not be considered an immediate problem to management as the membership structure provides the business with predictable long-term income streams. Any erosion of income should be foreseeable and therefore able to be rectified. However, the time is fast approaching for Pure to get back to its core values; the values that drew people from other facilities to Pure in the first instance.

For the purposes of this letter, I’ve tried to organize the myriad of critical commentary from members into a few key themes:

Pure staff (whether on reception, instructors, personal trainers, or cleaners) are generally perceived by members to be rude and arrogant. The terrific recruitment profiling from the business inception has been diluted with a less robust group of people that don’t have appropriate training in customer service/relations. These days the staff have a casual indifference to members - they never smile, never say hello, never offer to help with equipment, never replace weights etc. Instead, they tend to chat among themselves and create an environment where members almost feel they are intruding by being there. “Gangs” of sometimes six personal trainers working out together in the middle of the day is a potent image of this that is highly offensive. Members are the customers. Pure is a premium product. Pure members should be treated in the same way as a customer walking into a luxury retail boutique, or as a guest would be treated in a 5-star hotel.

The change room facilities at most Pure venues are under-designed for peak capacity. No business can afford to design to nth degree, but as usage conditions create greater demand tension, there needs to be a response in the facility capacity. There is also talk from men and women around the town about the lack of cleanliness in Pure’s shower area. One member I spoke with suggested the showers receive a comprehensive clean every quarter even if it meant shutting them down for a day. Ultimately management should decide how to deal with this issue, but it does need to be solved as sanitary dissatisfaction can be a powerful deterrent to extending membership.

The system of reserving a place in group classes has become highly disconcerting for members. Whilst I have no personal experience of this, it is something over a dozen friends have mentioned to me in the last month. The idea that Pure creates an advance booking process to deal with high levels of demand seems reasonable. However, when members are continuing to pay (on a monthly basis) a premium price for a product/service, they expect to be able to use it in the same way as when they bought it. Upon investigation of this issue, I learnt that there is an idiotic system whereby a member must call within a prescribed time period (11:15am or later) to reserve a place for a lunchtime class, not before, as would be a more customary first-come-first-served approach. Understandably for most people who work, it is difficult to always be available to make the vital call at the prescribed time. This is an example of Pure losing its ‘member-centric’ ethos and deteriorating to a disinterested corporate mindset that is self-serving.

The function of this correspondence is not to descend into operational critique of Pure, but rather to highlight a concerning erosion in the quality of the lifestyle experience Pure aspires to provide. Sitting silently in judgment or worse, whining to fellow members will only perpetuate the sense of ill-feeling rising within the member ranks. Instead, I want to help preserve a great business by drawing attention to these issues.

It may be worth considering the creation of an advisory committee whose composition includes selected Pure management and a few ordinary members. This would be seen as a real commitment to customer service. Another way forward might be overhaul the member feedback process and professionalize the manner in which member comments are dealt with (coupled with an open acknowledgment that Pure wants to “better understand what is important to members …”). It’s not too late for Pure to turn this into a positive example of corporate agility in reacting to customer needs.

Please accept my apologies for the presumptive nature of this letter. I hope you will appreciate my only intent is to help your business maintain its premier position as Asia’s leading lifestyle group.

Yours sincerely,

Morgan Parker

Sunday, April 26, 2009

In the last week I've watched the world celebrate Earth Day and Australians and New Zealanders remember ANZAC Day. In fact I wasn't just watching, I was also feeling the emotion of these two days as I reflected on their meaning.

ANZAC day is now bigger than ever in terms of engaging people's emotions and galvanising our thoughts on all the servicemen who lost their lives. At different points over the last 80 years ANZAC day had almost been forgotten in the annual calendar as people went about their lives with unconscious disassociation. Not any more. It is now seen as a sign of national patriotism to actively participate in the ceremonies of 25 April. When I was growing up I remember seeing the grainy images of Gallipoli each ANZAC day as a handful of Australians, usually direct descendants of soldiers who died there, conducted their own intimate remembrance ceremony. These days going to Gallipoli is the closest thing Australians have to the Islamic pilgrimage to Mecca. So many people now make the trip to Turkey every year that grandstands have been built to accommodate the crowds. People with no particular connection to the place or the armed services, but with a strong sense of national pride and desire to be part a unifying albeit solemn occasion. Ironically Gallipoli and the battle fought there is nothing more than a footnote in military history when one considers the central role played by ANZAC soldiers in defeating the Germans in France, by breaking the Hindenberg Line, and in doing so changing the course of the war. It matters not to me as Gallipoli symbolises all the battles fought, won or lost in the course of two world wars. However, observing the modern day scale and fanfare of the Gallipoli ceremonies does remind me that even the history of war can't escape the meddling self-serving influence of the media. I wonder in another 80 years whether young Australians will even know the relative significance of battle at Gallipoli or what it symbolises? Time has an uncanny way of shaping history.

Earth Day was again both educational and inspiring to me this year. I really feel I'm now an active agent of change for a better environment. I think every human needs to individually come to terms with the environmental devastation we are causing the earth. Its like religion, no one can tell you to believe, each person reaches their own enlightenment in their own time. Luckily today's children are growing up with an environmental consciousness built into their base education. Aria already knows plastic bags clog our ecosystems, cars pollute our air, that she needs to turn off the light when she leaves a room, and not to let the water run while she is brushing her teeth! So it seems we have achieved massive progress in awareness within a single generation. I think I've always been relatively alert to environmental issues from an intellectual perspective, but struggled with the practical side of things, constantly asking myself: "how can I make a real difference, I'm only one person ?". Many people share my disillusionment and feeling of helplessness. So we all persist with our daily lives allowing ourselves to be paralysed into inactivity, yet preaching the environmental mantra in some abstract way to rationale our own sense of morality. I have tried to absorb the scientific teachings over the last 10 years and in Asia I have almost constantly lived with environmental degradation surrounding me (except Japan, which is an amazing social role model, where an environmentally responsible lifestyle has become an accepted way of life). It is easy when you watch An Inconvenient Truth to be physically and emotionally disturbed, but at the same time so daunted by these realities that its easier to turn it off and pretend for just a little bit longer that it happening 'over there', somewhere else, not here in my city or on my street. For the average person the destruction of our world is not a daily thought yet. For me, its fair to say I have been building up to this environmental awakening for a while. Earth Day this year was a culmination not just because I re-learnt how incredibly dire our situation is but because for the first time I felt it is really happening.

For the last 12 months I have been rejecting plastic bags whenever I buy something, instead I just take the items into my own bag or just simply carry them unwrapped. It started out as my own little rebellion against the status quo of shops unnecessarily wrapping everything in plastic, but it then turned into a mini research assignment as I studied the responses of shopkeepers to my request for no wrapping or carry bag. I do it everywhere I go and I've become more and more assertive in my rejection of the plastic bags. I now include an environmental message to the shopkeeper as I reject the bags, hoping other customers will hear me. The looks on faces when I do this range from complete confusion and incomprehension to smiles and congratulations. My secret hope is that by rejecting plastic bags maybe one day the shop keepers I've met might decide to resist the dumb automated process of handing one out to every customer and instead ask "do you need a bag with that?". That would be progress.

I believe we are reaching a tipping point of awareness, more and more people are seeing the light every day, we have got to change the way we live. My guess is sometime in the next 10 years there will be massive social movement globally towards a new way of life. Not to say the change will happen overnight, it will still be gradual but momentum is noticeably picking up. Politics remains the greatest hurdle to overcome. 5 years ago it was politics and economics, but rapidly creative minds are finding a way to make being eco-friendly also financial viable. Now getting politicians to force big business to change is the key.

When I was a kid, "environmentalists" were considered weirdos or alternates, called tree-huggers and looked upon by 'civilised' people as no-hopers or trouble-makers who had nothing better to do with their time. Now I'm sitting here thinking to myself there is no better use for my time.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

It's Surreal Sliding Sideways

Apart from the deafening thump of bad economic news every hour of every day, the most resonate sense I have is that life has become a series of surreal days where nothing really happens. Sure, we all go to work (or at least some of us do), we go to events, we go to the gym, we pick up our kids from school, we all continue the daily regime and routine of that life we remember, but something doesn't feel right. Its like that dream you have where you're running towards something just out of focus in the distance, running and running, but you never quite get there, you wake up before seeing the destination in definitive reality. Maybe its like a hangover, a semi-permanent one, where that feeling of disorientation, slight depression and fragmented memories of the night before drag on for months. Maybe its the fact that nothing in the business world seems to be moving forward, sure people are talking about the future, even planning the future, but always in the context of a recently toxic past and the desperate reality of the present. There are whole weeks lost as every conversation you're in, or overhearing, is circling around the same topic discussed in the same shell-shocked way.

When this dream-like reality is over, I wonder how we will collectively and individually reflect on these lost days of 2008 and 2009. For many it will be like pages of a flip-calendar that didn't get bound leaving no trace or record, for others the blueish blur of watching a Bloomberg screen for too many hours. For me it will have been the most interesting of times, to observe in real-time a transformation of society around me. Other than my dear grandmother in Australia who at 85 has seen it all before, and Aria at 6 years old who remains focused on school, extra-curricular activities and negotiating for lollies; every other little facet of my life and the world I interact with, seems to have been turned upside down.

There are literally dozens of examples of economic theory playing out in the real world today, a radical one has been at the gym. Many businesses operate under the 80/20 rule: where 20% of your customers account from 80% of your sales. For a gym that means 20% of your members represent 80% of your usage or 'check-ins'. On a separate note, I'm also told that 30% of members who sign up for a 12 month contract, use the gym for the first month and then are never seen again! As you might expect, today gym membership sales are growing at a slower rate than in the heady years of 2005 through 2007, where a mere US$100 per month was chump change even if you only used it once each moon. The monthly cost of having a gym membership was compared to a round of after-work drinks at one of the many trendy bars that popped up around every major city in the world. What's most interesting is that 'check-in' rates at Hong Kong gyms are up 30% in the first three months of 2009. If that doesn't sound radical, try getting on to a running machine or bench press, or worse, getting a hot shower at any waking hour. The gyms are packed because the owners, knowing the 80/20 rule (see above) only design the gym capacity to meet a predictably poultry population of junkies that typically frequent the place. So now that people aren't going out for sit-down lunches or having after-work drinks as often, plus a rising population of out-of-work bankers are trying to work off their greed-bellies, the gyms are like toilets at half time at a rugby match.

Along with the 'budget' and 'mood' factors driving people out of bars and into the gym, I think there is a more subtle change taking place where people are becoming more human again - reflecting on what really matters in life. The thump of the news cycle is matched by a sense of quietness inside people's souls, like that silence in the eye of a tornado when all hell is breaking loose around you. This humane 're-balancing' of society is breaking down barriers that grew while society was single-mindedly pursing wealth and material gratification, where there was an expectation, not an aspiration, for the good life. This new reality is making communication between classes, cultures and genders easier with less hubris, less arrogance and hyped-up testosterone in the mix. Maybe a more tolerant society, focused less on individual progression and more on collective harmony, might be a silver-lining to otherwise surreal sideways slide.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Threshold Resistance

I recently spoke at the Business of Design Week in Hong Kong. It was an honour to be invited given the notable collection of speakers assembled from around the world. Moreover, it was a wonderful opportunity to break from the never ending talk of financial Armageddon and humbly delve into the unadulterated world of design.

I was particularly enthusiastic to discuss design in the context of business, my business, which is the creation and ownership retail space. I titled the presentation “Threshold Resistance” – a phrase coined by Alfred Taubman – founder of Taubman Centres and pioneer of the modern shopping centre business in America.
The audience of roughly 800 people were largely from the design world, be it architecture, product, digital or the environmental fields.

Excerpts of the presentation follow:

Design has always been important in the retail world, but to understand why design is so important today, it helps to look back at how retail venues have evolved throughout history to meet the changing needs of society.

The act of shopping has gone from being a necessary evil often performed by servants, to being the number one leisure activity of the 21st century.

Retail venues were traditionally nothing more than a place where merchants and consumers transacted. The tendency for people to exchange or sell goods in return for other goods led to the creation of the world’s first retail destinations. Sellers discovered they thrived alongside their direct and indirect competitors… the theory being that buyers wanted to compare, and thus, would come in greater numbers to locations where that comparison was possible.

While these rudimentary marketplaces were haphazardly expanding, so were individual retailers in their own right, thus creating a virtuous proliferation of choices for buyers, leading to a dramatic increase in visitation and aggregate consumption. In turn, the venues responded by becoming increasingly large and sophisticated; and for the first time became purpose-built destinations designed for interaction.
Today the shopping centre is the world’s dominant built environment for social exchange. It’s interesting that when you think of the world’s great architectural icons, I doubt anyone here would think of a shopping centre ……..

When considering design we could imagine that it springs from nowhere – the product of inspiration or a muse, and that designers exist in a realm of creativity that others do not. While this may be true in rare cases; it is more legitimate to think of design as a tool to meet the needs of business. For example, while hundreds of chairs may be designed, the ones that are eventually manufactured are the ones that resonate with business minds, as a proxy for the ultimate users. The same can be said for cars, electronic products, almost every subject of a design initiative.

When I think of something like the ubiquitous Blackberry. I wonder whether its origins trace to a spark of inspiration in a designer’s head, or whether it was the result of a consciously devised business strategy to respond to an observed need.

The reality is, good design invariably finds a way into marriage with business and vice versa. The best products are those which are borne from a collaboration of creative design and thoughtful business minds. Nothing in the world is truly new or original. So good design often involves a process of adapting or incrementally improving the product’s aptitude, and occasionally, as is the case with the blackberry and the ipod, making a great leap forward. In either case, it is the instructive interplay with business that helps a designer interpret the requirements of the user. In doing so, providing a rational foundation for the designer to apply creative freedom.

Designing retail space is a study in human psychology. Its not rocket science, but it is very hard to get right and requires a great deal of experience and patience.

The evidence is the hundreds of shopping centres being built today in emerging markets by new developers that fail to succeed. The most common error made when designing a new shopping centre is thinking about it as lines on an architectural plan or rental area that needs to be maximized at all costs. It’s not until you put yourself into the shoes of the customer, the retailer, the delivery man or garbage man that can really conceptualize the right solution for the space.

So good design in a retail sense necessarily becomes a response to and dialogue with the customer / user in all its forms. The challenge remains how to inspire and enthrall in an ever demanding and sophisticated consumer world, but at the same time create a functional venue that will last.

It may be strange for a retail developer to show an image of a coffee machine, but it highlights in one glance, some universal design principles we focus on. It was designed in the 1947 by Robbiati. It is timeless in its aesthetic appeal, simple, easily understood, and extremely functional. Often it is within simplicity that sustainable design is found. These sorts of products rebuff the commonly held view in Asia that new is better. In designing retail venues we strive for this same simplicity and durability. Great malls tend to have timeless design.

Perhaps Taubman’s most highly sought after mall today is Short Hills just outside of Manhattan in New Jersey. This project was built almost 30 years ago. If we think back to 1980 when Taubman was designing this shopping venue …….. Computers were rare. Televisions weren’t flat. Radios needed manual tuning. Music was played on vinyl and cassette tapes, and videos were amazing. There were no mobile phones, no internet, e-commerce, or electronic banking. Shops took notes and coins out of your wallet. So, how has Short Hills stayed relevant and successful over the last 30 years? One of the secrets is logical physical planning that has allowed the venue to evolve as the society evolved around it.

Until recently it has almost always been the more functional venues that were commercially successful and inversely the so-called beautiful malls that have been financially challenged. I say until recently, because we have sort of, just entered a golden age where we are beginning to see a more consistent convergence of form and function to produce beautiful shopping environments that are also doing lots of business. Maybe the powerful synergy of design and business working in unison is being realized?

The whole basis of this event is the interaction of business and design. To that end, I’d like to talk for a moment about the relationship between a retail developer and a retail architect.

In the simplest terms, it’s generally the developer who brings commercial parameters, functionality and urgency to the creative table, and the architect who brings the creativity. However, when a developer becomes an owner of a shopping centre, or dozens of shopping centres, the role definition begins to change. In these instances, the developer brings a wealth of operating experience that is priceless.

Designing a retail venue is not a perfect science, we learn as much through our mistakes as we do through observing what works. The on-going daily custodianship of a mall forces the owner to see the venue through the prism of the retailer and customer. That perspective then gets reflected in future renovations of that mall, and by the developer on the next project.

Contrast that intimate create -> observe -> interpret -> re-create continuum of the developer/owner, with the short-term retained involvement of an architect. No matter how experienced, how intellectually adept or how thoughtful the architect may be, it is a mighty task for he or she to appropriately balance all the nuances of such a complex social organism as a shopping centre, particularly when the architect often has additional aesthetic aspirations influencing their thought process as well. These slightly or widely diverging influences often create tension. But managed correctly, within that tension can come a lasting composition of both form and function. But at the end of the day, it is really the developer / owner that has to live with the property long-term, so in my view it’s the developer that needs to ultimately be responsible for the design.

If I had to distill the hundreds of design rules that Taubman applies to each project down to one axiom, it would be that of Threshold Resistance.

“Threshold resistance is defined as the physical and psychological barriers that stand between a customer and the sale of merchandise - the force that keeps the customer from opening the door and coming in over the threshold. One must understand that force and break down the barriers between art and commerce, between shoppers and merchandise, between high culture and popular taste.”

The best way to examine threshold resistance is to look at examples of it. Many would think that threshold resistance is a consequence of the constraints placed on a developer or designer during the conception process. But ironically, it is usually these very people that are responsible for creating the resistance in the first place.

Of course, different sites and regulatory requirements do heavily influence a developer and designer’s ability to create the ideal environment. To minimize or eliminate threshold resistance is an onerous aspiration that requires a dedication and precision not often associated with real estate developers.

Designing a large shopping centre is a highly iterative process that usually takes 18 months to complete. During the process a developer has literally hundreds of decisions to make. Decisions as major as: how floors should it have? to a decision about the colour of line markings in the car park.

Whatever the decision, we are always trying to reduce threshold resistance. In a sense we are endlessly trying to design the most fluid and seamless shopping experience conceivable. With no obstacles or frustrations built into the design.

Threshold resistance can be obvious, for example stairs. I’m sure everyone could predict the typical human response to being confronted with the option of climbing a flight of stairs. But there is the more subtle nuance of human nature that for every 3 people having a choice to go up or down a level, 2 will choose to go down. These sorts of psychological realities instruct Taubman’s design thinking.

Threshold resistance could also take the form of a sight line that is blocked by a column or lift. The reality being, that if a customer can’t see a store, they probably won’t shop in the store.

Threshold resistance doesn’t always present as a physical barrier, it might be an unfriendly looking shop attendant or a store temperature that is too cold or too hot. A mall that is too congested with merchandise, or too spacious. Whatever it is that reduces the ability for a customer to make a purchase is threshold resistance. To pursue the elimination of such forces is the most worthwhile aspiration when designing retail space.

Great retail design is not about fancy architects or grandiose architecture. Great retail design is about shaping social behaviour. Retail is the world’s biggest business, and shopping is the human race’s most fundamental activity.

What a responsibility to have.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

Buffett's analogy of the day

I don't want to make a habit of reciting the news but upon reading Warren Buffett's annual letter to Bershire Hathaway's shareholders today I felt obliged for its sense of reality is rather humorous.

He compared highly leveraged financial dealers seeking to avoid problems "to someone seeking to avoid venereal disease: its not just whom you sleep with, but also whom they are sleeping with. Sleeping around, can usually be useful for large derivatives dealers because it assures them government aid if trouble hits. In other words, only companies having problems that can infect the entire neighbourhood are certain to become a concern of the state. From this irritating reality comes The First Law of Corporate Survival for ambitious CEOs who pile on leverage and run large and unfathomable derivatives books: modest incompetence simply won't do it; it's mind-boggling screw-ups that are required."